Categories: Fundraising

Your Donor Engagement Experience Sucks!

If your donor engagement experience sucks, your organization might be in real big trouble because donors have seriously impressive memories.

According to Penelope Burk, 46% of respondents to her 2014 Burk Donor Survey “can vividly remember their first foray into philanthropy.” She continues by saying, “Donors say they experience a joyful rush when they make the decision to give but are often disappointed when the acknowledgement letter they get back is labored and distant.”
I think donors are also disappointed with the online experience many nonprofits provide.
Here’s a report from Dunham+Company and Next After (link removed – report now offline) that shows what happens if you give about 150 organizations $20 and document the process. Here are just a few of their findings below:

Email Registration
66% of email sign-up offers provide little-to-no interest to a potential donor.
Email Communication
More than one-third of organizations did not send a single email to new subscribers within the first 30 days of signing up.
79% of emails do not personalize the “To Line” with a first and last name.
56% of organizations did not make a single ask in the first 90 days!
Online Donation Experience
• While 80% present a clear call-to-action and 85% have a landing page design that matches the email, 84% were not optimized for mobile viewing.
Gift Acknowledgment
Most organizations (99%) understand the importance of thanking a donor, but 63% did not offer a donor “next steps” to take.
OUCH!
LIKE THIS BLOG POST? PLEASE SHARE IT AND/OR SUBSCRIBE
Greg Warner

Share
Published by
Greg Warner

Recent Posts

The Most Important Fundraising Metric: The 20-Year Relationship

When we conduct our Vital Signs Assessment, looking for indicators of fundraising success or struggle…

2 days ago

Why Organizations That Institute the Greatest Demands for Accountability Perform So Poorly

For the most part, everyone agrees that metrics are good. Accountability is good – even…

4 days ago

Don’t Just “Find” Donors; Build Relationships for Lasting Impact

"Where do we find donors?" I'm asked that question quite a bit. To begin, let's…

1 week ago

FREE Webinar: Fundraise Smarter, Not Harder: How to Leverage Automation for Optimal Results

FUNDRAISE SMARTER, NOT HARDER: How to Leverage Automation for Optimal Results May 8, 2024, at…

1 week ago

31 Donor Discovery Strategies That Sincerely Engage Wealthy Supporters

Prospect research, RFM, wealth screeners, and other hands-off/arm’s-length methods of donor discovery can only work…

2 weeks ago

Revolutionize Fundraising: Let’s Stop Making it Uncomfortable

If something about fundraising makes you uncomfortable, it isn't because there's something wrong with you…

2 weeks ago