I know, I disagree with many others on this issue.
But the value proposition offered to donors by donor-advised funds is fair and good. It motivates lots of people to move money into DAFs. Then money gets distributed. In fact, on average, about 15% to 20% of DAF dollars get distributed each year (depending on who you ask). Meanwhile, foundations must adhere to the ‘payout rule’ which refers to the fact that, by law, private non-operating foundations must distribute five percent of the value of their net investment assets annually in the form of grants. I couldn’t find how much actually gets distributed when I Googled the topic.
So, are the DAF holding pens just making money off the generosity of donors?
Yes, but if the money wasn’t transferred to a DAF, they’d be making money off the savings and investments of those same customers. Probably more money! Remember, most DAF dollars were in a bank account or investment account prior to hitting the DAF account. Those dollars weren’t under people’s mattresses!
In other words, think of it this way… The DAF got the donor halfway there for you. They got the donor to move the money from an investment account to an account earmarked for charity.
Related Posts:
>>Podcast: Engagement Fundraising: Donor-Advised Funds (Season 1, Episode 12)
>>Growth of Donor-Advised Funds
Greg,
I agree 100%! In addition to better awareness that our donor can (should) give from their DAFs, it should be a routine question as we get to know our donors better. “Do you have a donor-advised fund? What a great way to give to your favorite mission!” Why rely solely on the printed/electronic message?
Thank you for beating this drum.
Thanks for the pat on the back Adele! 🙂
“The DAF got the donor halfway there for you. They got the donor to move the money from an investment account to an account earmarked for charity”
Great point, Greg. And a positive way to look at DAFs! Thanks for this.
Thanks Debbie. Hope all is well with you and WETA.
Not only are DAFs a great philanthropic instrument, they are a way to help educate donors, especially ones new to giving and owning their wealth, about how their giving can elevate and sustain a social service or social justice interest. I have the joy of also helping donors create hybrid DAFs that allow others to participate, focus on a donor’s particular interest, and really gets wealth distributed back out to the communities that need it. As a foundation that focuses on redistributing wealth for social justice (yes, we use those words in our materials), DAFs have long been a way to “free the fruit.” The work of creating a donor-advised fund can be one of caring, joy, discovery, and love. Granting from DAFs is certainly one.
Good for you Carol. Thanks so much for sharing your perspective.
All great points. I will share with the NPs I consult with and feel DAF are a great revenue stream.
Great! Thanks so much Karen!